Platform
Menu
Contact Us

RESOURCES

Contact

9764 N Ash Ave Kansas City, MO 64157
(816) 382-2414 [email protected]
Do you want content like this delivered to your inbox?
Share

What’s Really Going On with Homeowner Insurance Rates, and Why It Matters More Than Ever

If you’ve opened your renewal letter lately and felt your stomach drop, you’re not alone. Homeowner insurance premiums are climbing across the country, and for many families, it’s starting to feel overwhelming.

As a real estate agent, I’m hearing the same question over and over again: “Why is my homeowner insurance going up again?”

Let’s unpack what’s really happening, what’s driving these increases, and how you can stay proactive about protecting your home (and your budget).

A Guide to Downsizing Your Parents Follow on Facebook
Share
Back to Articles

What’s Really Going On with Homeowner Insurance Rates, and Why It Matters More Than Ever

Beth Cree

I believe that bringing the highest quality of service begins with caring for the people you are working for...

I believe that bringing the highest quality of service begins with caring for the people you are working for...

Dec 1 6 minutes read

The Numbers Behind the Headlines

According to LendingTree (2024), the average U.S. homeowner insurance premium is now around $2,801 per year, up more than 40% since 2019. In some markets, that’s nearly doubled in less than five years.

NerdWallet (2025) reports a similar story, with a national average around $2,110, but even that number doesn’t tell the full picture. Premiums vary dramatically by location, home type, and local risk.

In fact, a U.S. Census Bureau report (2025) found that over 5.3 million American households are now paying more than $4,000 a year for homeowner insurance, with the sharpest increases hitting areas most exposed to severe weather and natural disasters.

And it’s not just about climate. The U.S. Treasury Department (2024) found that between 2018 and 2022, homeowner insurance premiums grew 8.7% faster than overall inflation, largely due to higher rebuilding costs and increased risk exposure.

Why Rates Are Rising

It’s easy to think insurers are just “raising rates,” but the truth is a mix of several compounding factors:

  • Extreme weather and natural disasters. Storms, floods, wildfires, and tornadoes are happening more frequently and causing record damage. Insurers are paying out more, and they’re passing those costs on to consumers.

  • Construction cost inflation. Building materials and labor costs are still high post-pandemic. When it costs more to rebuild a damaged home, premiums must rise to match.

  • Fewer insurers in high-risk areas. In states like California and Florida, several major carriers have stopped writing new policies. Fewer options = less competition = higher prices.

  • Older homes and outdated infrastructure. Older roofs, wiring, or siding increase a home’s risk profile, and insurers price that in.

It’s a perfect storm that’s leaving many homeowners wondering how to plan for their next renewal.

What This Means for You as a Homeowner

Even if you’re not in a high-risk area, rising insurance rates can impact your monthly housing costs, home value, and even buyer demand in your neighborhood.

Here’s why it matters:

  • Affordability. When insurance premiums rise, your total cost of homeownership rises too, which can impact how buyers evaluate your home if you decide to sell.

  • Market value. Buyers today are factoring in not just price, but total monthly cost (mortgage + taxes + insurance). Homes with higher insurance costs can feel less affordable, even at the same sale price.

  • Future planning. If you’re considering a move or a downsize, comparing insurance costs in different zip codes should be part of your plan, right alongside mortgage rates and taxes.

How to Stay Ahead

Here are a few simple, practical steps to help you stay proactive:

  1. Review your current policy. Don’t let it auto-renew without a conversation. Ask your insurer about expected rate changes and available discounts.

  2. Shop around. Every company uses different formulas for risk. A few quotes can make a big difference.

  3. Ask about home updates. A new roof, updated electrical, or security system can lower your premium.

  4. Consider your deductible. A slightly higher deductible can reduce your monthly cost, just make sure it’s still manageable in an emergency.

  5. Lean on your real estate professional. I can help you evaluate how rising insurance costs may affect your home’s market value or buyer interest.

While the numbers can feel discouraging, it’s important to remember: this isn’t a housing crisis  it’s a market recalibration. The price moderation we’re seeing in housing and insurance is part of the industry finding balance after several years of intense volatility.

You’re still sitting on tremendous equity (home values nationwide have risen 45% since 2020, according to Zillow’s 2025 data), and that equity can give you options if you ever need to adjust your financial picture.

Rising insurance costs are becoming a new normal, but with awareness and planning, you can stay ahead. The key is understanding the “why,” adjusting your strategy, and making choices that protect both your home and your peace of mind.

If you’d like to see how your insurance rates compare to local averages or want to review how these costs might affect your next move, I’m happy to connect you with trusted local insurance partners and help you run the numbers.